Overrated vs. Underrated: Equestrian Edition

In the world of horses, style and substance constantly collide. Some trends take off purely because they look good in an Instagram post, while others quietly elevate your ride in ways that actually matter. So, what’s worth the investment, and what’s just an expensive distraction? Let’s break it down.

Overrated: Expensive Tall Boots

There’s something about a pair of custom boots that feels like a rite of passage. They’re beautiful, they’re polished, they scream “I have my life together.” But do they actually make you ride better? No. A well-made off-the-rack pair will do the job just as well—without the stress of destroying something that costs as much as a month of board. If you want them, great. But if you’re convincing yourself they’re a need? They’re not.

Underrated: A Good Saddle Pad

Saddle pads don’t get nearly enough credit. They’re literally the barrier between your horse and your saddle, and yet most people treat them like an afterthought. The right one can make a huge difference in your horse’s comfort, especially if you ride a lot. Skip the trendy, overpriced ones covered in logos and look for something breathable, shock-absorbing, and well-shaped. It’s a small investment that pays off in the long run.

Overrated: Name-Brand Breeches

Are they gorgeous? Yes. Do they fit like a dream? Usually. Are they worth an entire paycheck? Debatable. The truth is, there are plenty of brands making breeches that look and feel just as good for half the price. If you love them and want to splurge, go for it. But if you’re just looking for something that’s comfortable, flattering, and holds up to daily barn life, you don’t need to drop $300.

Underrated: Plain Cotton Lead Ropes

We’ve all fallen for the fancy lead ropes—the ones with the extra clips, the braided details, the “new and improved” materials. And yet, nothing holds up quite like a basic cotton lead rope. It’s comfortable in your hands, lasts forever, and somehow never disappears into the barn black hole the way the expensive ones do. Functional, durable, and usually under $20. Sometimes simple is best.

Overrated: Matching Sets for Every Ride

Is it satisfying when your saddle pad, polos, and bonnet are all the same color? Absolutely. Is it necessary? Not at all. Your horse couldn’t care less, and half the time, those trendy colors are out of style by next season anyway. A few high-quality, neutral staples will serve you better than chasing every new release.

Underrated: A Trainer Who Actually Listens

We talk a lot about tack, apparel, and what’s in our grooming kits, but at the end of the day, nothing impacts your riding more than your trainer. A big-name coach with an impressive resumé is great, but if they don’t actually listen to you? You’re wasting your time. The right trainer will challenge you, support you, and help you improve in ways no piece of equipment ever could.